The following are the current list of Plum Mustangs alumni who play or played in the NFL.
Geoff Brown - Drafted by Cleveland Browns - Outside Linebacker
Pat McAfee - Drafted by Indianapolis Colts 2009 - present, Kicker/Punter
Frank Marchlewski - Drafted by L.A. Rams in 1965. Played 6 NFL seasons with L.A. Rams, Atlanta Falcons & Buffalo Bills - Offensive Lineman
Andy Matto - Drafted by L.A Rams In 1953. Also Played for Chicago Cardinals - Offensive Lineman
Matt Morgan - Two seasons with the St. Louis Rams. Offensive Lineman
Scott Urch - One season with the New York Giants - 1987
Vic Zucco - Drafted by Chicago Bears In 1957 Started 4 seasons at Defensive back & Kick Returner